HomeJudiciaryGuard Against Political, Financial, Social, Personal Pressures,, CJN Tells New Justices

Guard Against Political, Financial, Social, Personal Pressures,, CJN Tells New Justices

News Investigators/ Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN) Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun has urged the newly sworn in Court of Appeal Justices to guard against political, financial, social and personal pressures.

Kekere-Ekun made the call at the swearing in ceremony of the newly appointed 12 Court of Appeal Justices on Tuesday in Abuja.

“In the courts from which most of you have been elevated, you have ordinarily exercised jurisdiction as the sole presiding Judge.

“You heard the parties, controlled proceedings, evaluated the evidence, resolved the issues and delivered decisions in the exercise of your individual judicial authority.

“At the Court of Appeal, you will sit with other Justices in panels, deliberate collectively and arrive at decisions through a process of judicial engagement.

“This calls for a team work, a willingness to engage with the views of colleagues, test your initial conclusions and consider issues from perspectives that may differ from your own”.

The CJN added that the effectiveness of a collegiate court depends on the quality of  engagements.

She encouraged them to approach panel conferences through preparation with intellectual openness and mutual respect.

“Listen attentively, contribute meaningfully and be prepared to reconsider a position where the arguments persuade you to do so.

“The ability to listen and reflect is a mark of judicial maturity. Seek guidance from your more experienced colleagues on the appellate Bench”.

She, however added that collegiality must never come at the expense of individual judicial independence.

“Sitting in a panel does not diminish the personal responsibility each justice bears for his or her judicial opinion.

“You must decide according to the law and your conscience, without being unduly influenced by seniority, reputation, personal affinity or the desire for unanimity.

“Where, after careful consideration, your view differs from that of the majority, you must have the courage to maintain and express it with clarity, restraint and respect.

A well reasoned dissent, she said, was a legitimate feature of appellate adjudication and may, in time, contribute to the development or reconsideration of the law,” she advised.

She said that differences of judicial opinion must never become personal differences as robust debate is essential to sound deliberation, but it must be conducted with courtesy and professional discipline.

“The strength of a collegiate court lies in the quality of its reasoning and the integrity of its deliberations, rather than in an artificial appearance of unanimity.

“The court of appeal decisions have far-reaching implications for the administration of justice and provide guidance to lower courts, legal practitioners, public institutions and citizens.

She reminded them that their responsibility extends beyond determining whether a decision should be affirmed or set aside.

She urged them to promote consistency in the application of the law, clarify legal principles, correct errors where necessary and contribute to the coherent development of our jurisprudence.

Kekere-Ekun said that particular care is required when reviewing findings of fact and the evaluation of evidence, especially where the appellate court has not had the opportunity to observe the witnesses.

The task, she added, was to correct errors where they are established, while respecting findings that are properly supported by the evidence and the applicable law.

She urged them to give equal attention to the quality and clarity of their judgments.

NAN

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -sponsored

Most Popular

Recent Comments

This is our collective consensus , no retreat no surrender ,all elections results must be transmitted at real time enough of taking us for morons in their cages , on Electronic Transmission Without Mandatory `Real-time’ Provision Is Useless – Coalition
This is our collective consensus , no retreat no surrender ,all elections results must be transmitted at real time enough of taking us for morons in their cages , on Electronic Transmission Without Mandatory `Real-time’ Provision Is Useless – Coalition
Whoever is responsible for all of this must have to go. on Delay In Wage Award Payment Arrears No Longer Acceptable – Civil Servants